The Progressive National Security Era
While President Obama's interview
with Al Arabiya -- his first
interview since taking office on
Jan. 20 -- signaled a new rhetorical posture toward the world, his
initial appointments and directives have shown that, unlike
the previous administration, this president intends to put policy
weight behind that rhetoric and effect a significant change in U.S.
foreign policy. In the first week of his administration, Obama "gave
his national security team a new mission to end the
war in Iraq," as he had promised
during the campaign. The President
"revoked
all executive directives issued by the CIA
between Sept. 11, 2001, and Jan. 20, 2009,"
that have been used to
justify
torture. He created a
commission to examine options for closing
the Guantanamo Bay prison, which
has been a source of outrage
around
the world, with the goal of shutting it down within a year. The
President empowered high-level envoys for two key areas -- George
Mitchell for the
Israeli-Palestinian conflict and Richard
Holbrooke for Afghanistan and
Pakistan -- signaling that these
conflicts will receive the sort of presidential attention that they
sorely lacked over the last eight years.
HITTING
THE GROUND RUNNING: In
December, even before Obama took office, it was clear that he and
his national security team intended to enact "a
sweeping shift of priorities and resources in the national security
arena." Reporting on the
selection of Hillary Clinton as
Secretary of State, James L. Jones as National Security Adviser, and
Obama's retention of Robert Gates as Secretary of Defense, the New York
Times quoted a senior Obama adviser as saying that all three have
embraced "a
rebalancing of America's national security
portfolio" after an emphasis on
military capabilities during
the Bush years. Another senior adviser, Denis
McDonough, noted that the
new direction was "a
pragmatic solution to a
long-acknowledged problem,"
signifying a recognition of "the need
to strengthen and integrate the other tools of
national power to succeed against unconventional threats." Appearing
before Congress yesterday to discuss Afghanistan, Gates
affirmed this view, making clear that he sees "no
purely military solution" for
the
insurgency, preferring a "fully integrated civil-military strategy."
GENERATING
NEW IDEAS: Many of
the ideas that underpin the Obama administration's new foreign
policy direction have been developed by progressive thinkers at or
associated with the Center for American Progress. In 2004, amid the
unilateralist militarism of President Bush's "war on terror,"
CAP-affiliated scholar Suzanne
Nossel argued that progressives
had "a
historic opportunity to reorient U.S. foreign policy around an
ambitious agenda...that renders
more effective the fight against
terrorism but that also goes well beyond it -- focusing on the smart
use of power to promote U.S. interests through a stable grid of allies,
institutions, and norms." Likewise, a 2005 CAP report, Integrated
Power, called for "wholesale
changes in the way the United
States engages with
the developing world." Integrated Power identified three main threats
faced by the United States: "global terrorist networks, extreme
regimes, and
weak and failing states." It argued that the Bush administration's
approach "has not only been
ineffective at confronting these threats, but it has eroded America's
global leadership position and exposed us to new dangers." In 2008, CAP
published a series of reports on "Sustainable
Security," which Senior Fellow
Gayle Smith described as "a
fundamental shift from our
outdated notion of national security
to a more modern concept of
sustainable security -- that is, our security as defined by the
contours
of a world gone
global and shaped by our common humanity." In their
book The
Prosperity Agenda, authors Nancy
Soderberg, former U.S.
ambassador to the United Nations, and Brian Katulis, a Senior Fellow at
CAP, argued that ameliorating global deprivation and
improving governance must be seen as a U.S. national security
imperative, one that requires the application of the full range of
American power, not just military.
FAREWELL
TO FAILED POLICIES: In his
inaugural address, President Obama stated, "We
reject as false the choice between our safety and our ideals."
His
first presidential directives have shown a commitment to both. Some
conservatives have tried to argue that Obama's national security
policies don't represent much of a change from the Bush administration.
Appearing on on NBC's "Today" show, former Bush adviser Karl
Rove
said Obama's team is "a
reminder that continuity exists particularly in our foreign and
international relations."
Thankfully, this is untrue. Where there
is continuity, it is only because Bush, in the last years
of his administration, had out of necessity moved away from the more
extreme conservative policies that have proven so disastrous for
America's security. Bush's acceptance of a withdrawal
timeline from Iraq, after years
of refusing one, and his 11th
hour attempt to broker Israeli-Palestinian peace,
are examples of
these shifts. But unlike the previous president, in the first days of
administration, Obama has shown -- with both words and deeds --
that he will not wait until the last days of his term to confront
America's national security challenges, and that he will embrace new
solutions for dealing with those challenges.
|
|
|
|
Congress gave approval yesterday to the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act, which will give women and minorities "new tools to challenge pay discrimination in the workplace." The bill is expected to be the first significant legislation signed by President Obama.
THINK
PROGRESS: Senate Minority Leader
Mitch McConnell (R-KY): Bush was a ‘burden’ on my
party.
WONK
ROOM: Progressive House members
launch Sustainable Energy and
Environment Coalition.
YGLESIAS:
Conservatives prepare to abandon their newfound love for the
Congressional Budget Office.
MEDIA
MATTERS:
NPR's Juan Williams says Michelle Obama is "Stokely Carmichael in a
designer dress."
ILLINOIS: Listen
to the FBI's wiretaps
of Gov. Rod Blagojevich (D).
CALIFORNIA:
"More than 236,000 homes were lost to foreclosure in California last
year, topping the previous nine years combined."
TEXAS:
More than 160,000 Texas children have parents who can't get
state
help to pay medical expenses.
"We heard him [Obama] say that he we shouldn't paint Islam with a
broad brush. Who does? That's a straw man."
-- Washington Post columnist Charles Krauthammer, 1/27/09
"From Nigeria to Sudan to Pakistan to Indonesia to the Philippines,
some of the worst, most hate-driven violence in the world today is
perpetrated by Muslims and in the name of Islam. "
-- Krauthammer, 12/6/02







