by Faiz Shakir, Amanda Terkel, Satyam Khanna, Matt Corley, Ali Frick, Benjamin Armbruster, and Matt Duss
Douglas Feith's Blame Game
In a new memoir the Washington Post calls "a
massive score-settling work," former Undersecretary of Defense for
Policy Douglas Feith defends himself from charges that his Pentagon
office politicized pre-war Iraq intelligence. Feith blames former
Secretary of State Gen. Colin
Powell, the CIA, U.S.
Army General Tommy Franks, former Coalition Provisional Authority head
L. Paul Bremer, and almost
everyone else but himself and former Defense Secretary Donald
Rumsfeld for mishandling
the run-up to the Iraq war and the
subsequent occupation. The Post obtained a 900-page manuscript of
Feith's book, entitled, War and Decision: Inside the Pentagon at the
Dawn of the War on Terrorism. After the 9/11 attacks, Feith headed up
the Office
of Special Plans (OSP), which was created "to
find evidence...that Saddam
Hussein had close ties to Al Qaeda, and that Iraq had an enormous
arsenal of chemical, biological, and possibly even nuclear weapons that
threatened the region and, potentially, the United States." Retired
U.S. Air Force Lt. Karen Kwiatkowski, who worked under Feith in
the OSP, characterized the program's purpose as "developing
propaganda and pushing...an agenda on Iraq." Kwiatkowski also
said that OSP had "developed pretty sophisticated propaganda lines
which were fed
throughout government, to the Congress, and even internally to the
Pentagon" to make the case that Saddam was an imminent threat.
POLITICIZING INTELLIGENCE: In
February 2007, the Pentagon's Inspector General concluded that the
OSP under Feith had "developed,
produced, and then disseminated alternative intelligence
assessments on the Iraq and al Qaida relationship...that were
inconsistent with the consensus of the
Intelligence Community, to senior decision-makers" and that
Feith's intelligence briefings to the President presented
"conclusions
that were not fully supported by the available intelligence." Sen.
Carl Levin (D-MI) stated that the report was "a
devastating condemnation of inappropriate activities
in the DoD policy office" that demonstrated "that intelligence
relating to the Iraq/al-Qaeda
relationship was manipulated by high-ranking officials in the
Department of Defense to support the administration's decision to
invade Iraq." When asked about
the activities
of the Office of Special Plans, CIA director Gen. Michael Hayden stated
before
Congress in May 2006 that he was "not
comfortable" with Feith's approach to intelligence analysis. "I wasn't aware of a lot of the
activity going on, you know,
when it was contemporaneous with running up to the war," Hayden said. "No,
sir, I
wasn't comfortable." The Senate Intelligence
Committee will also soon release a new report criticizing Bush
administration officials "for
making assertions that failed to reflect
disagreements or uncertainties in the underlying intelligence on
Iraq." Many of these statements were made based upon analyses produced
by Feith's office at the Pentagon, which posited a working
relationship
between Saddam and al Qaeda and claimed that Saddam was in possession
of weapons of
mass
destruction.
A PREDETERMINED INVASION: Feith's account of the lead-up to
the Iraq invasion also offers more evidence that President Bush was
resolved to invade Iraq, regardless of international opinion and
irrespective of whether inspectors found evidence of an Iraqi weapons
program.
Feith writes that Bush declared "war is inevitable" in a National Security Council meeting
in December
2002, even as he
continued
to insist in public that no decision had been made. On December 31,
2002, Bush said to reporters, "I
hope this Iraq situation will be resolved peacefully. ... I hope
we're not headed to war in Iraq," and "I hope this can be
done peacefully." On Jan.
2, 2003, Bush told reporters that he was "hopeful
we won't have to go war." On March 6, 2003, Bush said in a
press conference that no
decision had been made to use force against Iraq, even though two
weeks earlier, he told then-Spanish president Jose Maria Aznar that the
U.S. would "be
in Baghdad at the end of March."
THE INCOMPETENCE DODGE:
Responding to charges that his office "politicized" intelligence, Feith
reportedly claims in his book that it was the CIA that was politicizing
intelligence by discounting evidence of ties between Saddam and
al Qaeda. In other words, Feith claims that the CIA was delinquent in
ignoring evidence of a
relationship that did not, in fact, exist. Feith's charges of
failure against those initially responsible for the occupation of Iraq
will likely be seized upon by those seeking to cast the war, as Feith
does, as a good idea ruined by poor implementation -- a line of
argument
which has been termed "the
incompetence dodge" because it attempts to present the Iraq
disaster as a failure of implementation, not of conception. While he
has harsh criticisms for many people, the Washington Post notes that
Feith treats Rumsfeld "with almost complete
admiration."
|
|
|
|
The research team that brings you The Progress Report and ThinkProgress.org needs summer interns! Click here for more information.
"The number of foreign visitors to the United States set a record in 2007 for the first time since before the September 11 attacks on the United States."
MARYLAND:
State lobbyists "are still finding ways to help fill campaign coffers
for the legislators they seek to influence."
MICHIGAN:
Home heating bills rise "dramatically."
ECONOMY:
At least 25 states face budget shortfalls in fiscal year 2009.
THINK
PROGRESS: Former White House adviser Karl Rove: "I fully
expect to be indicted by the end of
the year."
THE
SWAMP: Former U.N. Ambassador
John Bolton joins Kenneth Starr at
the Kirkland & Ellis law firm.
TPM
MUCKRAKER: Rep. Henry Waxman
(D-CA) calls for investigations into
Blackwater's questionable tax practices.
WASHINGTON
INDEPENDENT: The Brookings Institution's Michael
O'Hanlon's explanation of his
benchmarks for Iraqi political progress doesn't actually explain much.
"Al Gore's opulent lifestyle and his virtuous plea to save the planet from global warming don't mesh."
-- Competitive Enterprise Institute, 3/8/08
VERSUS
"Short of tearing it down and staring anew, I don't know how it could have been rated any higher."
-- Kim Shinn, U.S. Green Building Council, 12/13/07, on Gore's home receiving the Council's "second-highest rating for sustainable design"







