HUMAN RIGHTS
The Mafia Administration
In an interview
with The New Yorker magazine, Army Maj. Gen. Antonio Taguba,
who led the Pentagon's investigation into the
abuses at Abu Ghraib, revealed that he believed high-level military
officials, including then-Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, knew
about the abuses at the Iraqi prison. But Taguba had been unable to
write about it because his inquiry was narrowly focused on the 800th
Military Police brigade stationed at the prison. "I
suspected that somebody was giving them guidance, but I could not print
that," Taguba told reporter Seymour Hersh. Taguba, who is just now
making his first public comments about his investigation, also revealed
that the Pentagon forced him to retire early because of his
aggressive pursuit of the issue, and that he had been
threatened over the report by the then-commander of Central Command
Gen. John Abizaid, who told him that "you and your report will be
investigated." Taguba said the comment made him feel like he was in the
Mafia rather than the Army. "I’d been in the Army thirty-two
years by then, and it was the first time that I thought I
was in the Mafia," he said. Though there have been a
dozen government
investigations and multiple reports by international human rights
groups, responsibility for the grisly abuse at the military prison has
yet to reach beyond the soldiers stationed at the prison. Despite
reports like Taguba's, which described the abuse as "systemic,"
true accountability up the chain of command has yet to occur.
UP THE CHAIN OF COMMAND: "From
what I knew, troops just don't take it upon themselves to initiate what
they did without any form of knowledge of the higher-ups," Taguba told
Hersh. In his dicussion with Hersh, Taguba has become the first general
to assert that Lt. Gen. Ricardo Sanchez, the army commander in Iraq at
the time of the Abu Ghraib abuses, "knew
exactly what was going on" at the prison. According to Taguba, "in
the fall of 2003 -- when much of the abuse took place -- Sanchez
routinely visited the prison, and witnessed at least one
interrogation." In June 2004, the Washington Post reported that Sanchez
had "approved letting senior officials at" Abu Ghraib "use
military dogs, temperature extremes, reversed sleep patterns, sensory
deprivation, and diets of bread and water on detainees whenever
they wished." In an FBI memo obtained by the American Civil Liberties Union, similar techniques were
also authorized by an Executive Order from President Bush with the
explicit direction that "certain techniques can only be used if very
high-level authority is granted." Taguba also asserts
that Rumsfeld's testimony to the Senate and the House Armed
Services Committees on May 7, in which he claimed to have had no idea
of the extensive abuse until right before his testimony, "was
simply not true."
'PROTECT THE BIG PICTURE': According
to a senior intelligence official who spoke to Hersh, "there
were some in the Pentagon and the White House who 'didn't think the
photographs were that bad'" because they focused on enlisted
soldiers rather than intelligence officers. "A Pentagon consultant on
the war on terror also said that the "basic strategy was 'prosecute the
kids in the photograph but protect the big picture.''" Hersh
found at least one incident of the Pentagon protecting a higher-up
involved in the detainee policy at Abu Ghraib. In 2003, the Pentagon
transferred Maj. Gen. Geoffery Miller from Guantanamo Bay to Abu
Ghraib, where he was tasked "to survey the prison system there and find
ways to improve the flow of intelligence." One of Miller's key
recommendations was that the military police should be utilized in
"setting the conditions for successful exploitation of the internees."
After the revelations of abuse at Abu Ghraib surfaced in 2004, the
Pentagon opened an inquiry into complaints about similar abuse at
Guantanamo. The officer in charge of the investigation, Lt. Gen.
Randall M. Schmidt, concluded that Miller "was responsible for the
conduct of interrogations that I found to be abusive and degrading."
Schmidt formally recommended that Miller be "held accountable" and
"admonished" for his role in the abuse, but that recommendation was
rejected by Lt. Gen. Bantz J. Craddock, a senior aide to Rumsfeld, who "absolved
Miller of any responsibility for the mistreatment of the prisoners."
Despite his apparent role in the implementation of abusive
interrogation techniques in both Guantanamo Bay and Baghdad, Miller was
the officer chosen to restore order at Abu Ghraib a month after
Taguba's report was filed.
CREDIBILITY LOST: Taguba
believes that the policies put forth by Rumsfeld and his aides have
hurt America in the world. "The whole idea that Rumsfeld projects --
'We're here to protect the nation from terrorism' -- is an oxymoron,"
says Taguba. "He
and his aides have abused their offices and have no idea of the values
and high standards that are expected of them. And they've dragged a
lot of officers with them." Indeed, the abuses uncovered at Abu Ghraib
have gone a long way towards harming America's credibility and moral
authority in the world, but steps can be taken towards restoring them.
In 2004, the Center for American Progress released a series of recommendations demonstrating how "President Bush can take steps to
prove America's credibility and show the world he takes the issue
seriously." Three years later, many of the suggestions still
stand as a reasonable approach to regaining America's moral
authority. Most importantly, Bush should "immediately establish a
Permanent Committee for Monitoring Prison Conditions to formally
oversee the prison system" as well as allowing "independent rights
organizations to monitor the conditions of detainees in all U.S.-run
detention facilities outside the United States."

ETHICS -- NEW REPORT REVEALS LAWMAKERS' USE OF 'CAMPAIGN FUNDS
TO PAY RELATIVES': A report released
today by the Citizens for Responsibility and Ethics in Washington
(CREW) finds that "96 members [of the House of Representatives] from 33
states: 44 Democrats and 53 Republicans" have used their positions to "financially benefit
their family members." Of those 96, CREW found that 72 members "spent
$5.1 million in campaign funds to pay relatives or their relatives'
companies or employers during the past six years." While the practice
of paying one's spouse or relatives for political work with campaign
funds is not illegal, Rep. Adam Schiff (D-CA) argues that "there's
simply been too much abuse." The new report finds that "Rep. Randy
Forbes's (R-VA) campaign committee paid his three
children over $45,000" and that "Rep. Zoe Lofgren's (D-CA) campaign
committee has paid her husband's two
businesses almost $350,000, mostly for event management, accounting
and fundraising services." Schiff and Rep. Mike Castle (R-DE) have
"introduced a
bill this month that would prohibit
congressional candidates from paying their spouses with campaign
funds and require campaigns to disclose close relatives on the
payroll." Rep. Chris Cannon (R-UT), who "paid six of his eight
children, in the range of $1,000 to $33,000, over the six-year period,"
defended his actions. His spokesman said, "It's cheap labor...they put
in a lot of work, and [Cannon] doesn't really have a problem with them
collecting a paycheck for it." CREW Executive Director Melanie Sloan
argues, however, that "paying relatives with campaign money gives the
impression that Congress members use their 'position as a profit center
for the family.'" Furthermore, she notes that "[a] member of Congress
would not be allowed to put that family member on their office payroll.
... [W]hy
should they [be allowed to] put them on the campaign payroll?"
MILITARY -- WALTER REED NOT EQUIPPED
TO DEAL WITH MENTAL HEALTH DISORDERS: The Veterans Affairs
administration is "battling
a crisis in mental health care." Veterans returning from Iraq,
one-fourth of whom display post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) and
other mental illness symptoms, "enter a VA system that chronically
loses records and sags with a backlog of 400,000 claims of all kinds."
Outdated diagnosis methods, medical records "riddled with obvious
errors," and shortages in trained personnel and treatment options
contribute to the crisis. According to a report commissioned by
Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, "there is not a coordinated
effort to provide the training required to identify and treat these
non-visible injuries, nor adequate research in order to develop the
required training and refine the treatment plans." At Walter Reed
Medical Center, where the majority of soldiers diagnosed with mental
problems are transferred, "the
Army has no PTSD center...and its psychiatric treatment is weak
compared with the best PTSD programs the government offers." The Army's
top hospital "lacks enough psychiatrists and clinicians to properly
treat the growing number of soldiers returning with combat stress" and
rarely offers individual or group therapy for PTSD. Medical experts and
"even VA's chief of mental health" have also admitted that the Army's
rules for mental health coverage and compensation "deny
thousands of claims." According to the Washington Post, "to qualify
for compensation, troops and veterans are required to prove that they
witnessed at least one traumatic event, such as the death of a fellow
soldier or an attack from a roadside bomb, or IED." Under the
system, soldiers living "in dread of exposure" to a roadside bomb
or death "don't qualify" for compensation. Those who do are "over-medicated
and treated with none of the urgency given the physically wounded."
IRAQ -- LOW EFFECTIVENESS OF
ESCALATION RAISES QUESTIONS OF LONG-TERM OCCUPATION IN IRAQ: Last week, a fatal bombing that destroyed the Samarra
Askariya mosque, which was also severely damaged one year earlier,
raised questions as to the efficacy of the U.S. troop escalation. U.S.
News and World Report reports this week that "[e]arly indications are far
from encouraging" for the escalation. "While sectarian killings
appear to have declined at least temporarily in the capital, the
Pentagon reports that overall violence levels nationwide remain as high
as ever. Indeed, even as U.S. troops boost their presence in some
Baghdad neighborhoods, many insurgents appear to have simply moved to
outlying provinces that now have a much thinner security presence."
Insurgents continue to attack American soldiers at record levels, for
example, with May being one of the deadliest months for
American forces in the entire war. Despite the clear evidence
against the escalation's effectiveness, administration and military
officials are attempting to play down expectations of progress by this
fall and instead are endorsing a protracted troop presence. Last week,
Gen. David Petraeus, the commanding U.S. general in Iraq, stated that "we haven't
even started the surge yet," despite nearly all of the 28,000
troops being in place at the time. Yesterday, on Fox News Sunday,
Petraeus admitted that he didn't
expect the "surge" to be done by September, the date set for
Petraeus's supposedly make-it or break-it report to
Congress. Petraeus then went on to endorse the "Korea
model" for Iraq, which envisions keeping troops in the country for
decades. "[T]ypically, I think historically, counterinsurgency
operations have gone at least nine or ten years," he said.
|

In Iraq's Diyala
province, U.S. soldiers are willing to risk teaming up
with Sunni militias to fight insurgent groups. Ali al-Adeeb, a
prominent Shiite lawmaker, said the United States is "trusting
people who have previously attacked American forces and innocent
people. They are trusting people who are loyal to the regime of Saddam
Hussein."
Fallout from the U.S. attorney scandal is "starting
to hit the [Justice] department in federal courtrooms around the
country."
Defense lawyers are "raising questions about the motives of government
lawyers who have brought charges against their clients," and "are
citing the furor over the U.S. attorney dismissals as evidence
that their cases may have been infected by politics."
"A federal grand jury in Washington, D.C., has
heard evidence about a remodeling project at Sen. Ted Stevens'
(R-AK) home as part of a burgeoning investigation into
corruption in Alaska."
On Tuesday, the Senate Finance Committee will take up "a major
reversal of energy tax policies,"
legislation that would "raise about $14 billion from oil companies over
10 years and would give about the same amount of money on new
incentives for solar power, wind power, cellulosic ethanol and numerous
other renewable energy sources."
"Seven children were killed in a U.S.-led coalition airstrike targeting suspected al-Qaida militants in eastern Afghanistan, a
coalition statement said Monday. The strike came hours after the deadliest
insurgent attack since the Taliban fell in 2001."
White House loyalists have begun arguing for a Libby pardon.
"[S]everal Republicans, who sense a movement in Libby’s favor,
said a
more likely possibility might be a presidential
commutation -- a reduction or elimination of Libby's 2 1/2-year
federal prison sentence.
Robert Novak writes that President Bush plans to go on a "veto offensive." Bush
has pledged to veto the homeland
security appropriations bill. After that, "Bush next plans vetoes of the energy-water and
interior-environment bills." Novak predicts Bush's vetoes will "trigger
an epochal political struggle in the months ahead."
And finally: For Father's Day, First Lady Laura
Bush gave the President "several ties she purchased during their recent
trip to Europe," and his daughters "gave him a CD they had made for him
to listen to while exercising." President Bush also "squeezed in a bike
ride at his ranch" and "spoke
to his father, former President George H.W. Bush, over
the phone."
|
|
|

"Just one day after a news that an internal audit found that FBI agents abused
a Patriot Act power more than 1000 times,
a federal judge ordered the agency Friday to begin turning over
thousands of pages of documents related to the agency's use of a
powerful, but extremely secretive investigative tool that
can pry into telephone and internet records."

MISSOURI:
A new law aimed at restricting access to abortions is forcing
changes at Planned Parenthood clinics.
TEXAS:
The mockingbird -- Texas's state bird -- has declined by 18 percent in
the past four decades in part due to "suburbanization."
ENVIRONMENT:
"Seven of the 32 states that test car emissions do not check vehicles
built before 1996 models," which are often the heaviest polluters.

THINK
PROGRESS: Gen. David Petraeus: escalation will not be done by
September, 50-year presence in Iraq is a "realistic assessment."
THINK
PROGRESS: Special Counsel probe advances into Karl Rove's
politicization of the government.
NEXT
HURRAH: Former Deputy Secretary of the Interior Steven Griles, who
pleaded guilty to obstructing a Senate inquiry into Jack Abramoff, is
now attempting to get a lighter sentence.
TALKING
POINTS MEMO: The press release for an upcoming PBS documentary on
the separation of church and state "reads like a pamphlet from Focus on
the Family."

"[T]he damage that's been done is enormous. And it breaks our hearts
that in fact someone didn't say, 'Wait, look, this is terrible. We need
to do something.' ... I wish we had known more, sooner, and been able
to tell you more sooner, but we didn't."
-- Then-Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, 5/7/04, testifying to
House Armed Services Committee about Abu Ghraib detainee abuse
VERSUS
"Taguba, watching the hearings, was appalled. He believed that
Rumsfeld's testimony was simply not true. 'The photographs were
available to him -- if he wanted to see them,' Taguba said."
-- New Yorker, 6/25/07,
on the reaction of Army Maj. Gen. Antonio M. Taguba, who led the Army's
Abu Ghraib investigation
|